How to Update Kitchen Cabinet Hardware in a 90s Home

Quick and Easy Tips for Updating Your Cabinet Hardware 

Wondering how to give your 90s home a refresh that won’t cost you an arm and a leg? Swapping out your kitchen hardware is one of the least expensive solutions that makes a big difference. With a few tweaks here and there, your kitchen cabinets can feel completely and totally transformed. Read on for our rule book on how to do it right – it’ll make your remodel steps a cinch to complete.

Many of my posts contain affiliate links including this one. If you click on an affiliate link and purchase something, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. The affiliate money I earn helps pay the fees to keep this site up and running. You can read our disclosure statement here. Thank you so much for your support.

TIP #1: Try to DIY First

If your hardware is in good condition, a little DIY can go a long way! So, first thing, before you go out and purchase all new hardware or fixtures, try a good old-fashioned coat of spray paint. Not only can you completely customize the look you want, but honestly, paint is one of the most inexpensive ways to upgrade your home. And you’d be surprised at just how much the look of a pull or light fixture can change with a more modern finish.

Wondering how to do it the right way? Check out these great articles to help you DIY like the pros: Porch Daydreamer, SF Gate, Our Hopeful Home.

RELATED: 10 Modern Honey Oak Kitchen Design Schemes with Colors & Finishes

TIP #2: Keep it Simple 

Drilling new hardware holes or plugging and painting existing ones can be headache-inducing. Try to use existing holes for a hardware swap whenever possible. Make sure to first note the type of hardware you have to help you narrow down your selection. As a rule of thumb, pulls typically use two screw holes while a single knob uses one. For pulls, measure from the center of one screw to the center of the other screw for proper sizing. Worried about not being able to use a style you really love? Fear not – there are endless possibilities in many different styles, both pull and knob, so you’re sure to find one you adore.

RELATED: Are White Kitchens Timeless or Trendy?

TIP #3: Keep Your Finishes Contemporary

90s finishes are usually shiny faux brass or a reddish oil-rubbed bronze, and while it’s definitely possible to find beautiful contemporary versions in these finishes, it’s much easier to search if you keep your finishes more contemporary. Matte black, brushed brass, brushed nickel, chrome, and more are great options to consider.

When introducing a new finish, make sure you have other matching finishes in your space to tie in the new hardware. Example of this would be in your light fixtures, appliances, plumbing fixtures or interior door hardware. A 75% to 25% ratio of two finishes works well.

RELATED: Tile Ideas & Inspiration

Pin this image for easy reference:

TIP #4: Keep Things Streamlined

There’s no denying that keeping things visually streamlined is key to avoiding the overly-ornate styles of the 90s. Stick to sleek lines and silhouettes. Not only is it a cleaner look overall, but it kicks those 90s vibes to the curb and invites instant contemporary class instead. Oh, and while you don’t necessarily need everything to be matchy-matchy, sometimes it’s better to keep your hardware consistent – think doorknobs, cabinet pulls, etc. – to keep things curated throughout your home. 

RELATED: Quartz vs. Granite, How to Choose the Right Countertop

RELATED: How Much Does it Cost to Paint Kitchen Cabinets?

TIP #5: Keep Things Interesting

Speaking of matching – don’t be afraid to mix and match a few different finishes in a room! Mixed metals can look amazing when done right. Just remember to keep the same finish together on one plane. It avoids too much chaos (e.g. all lower cabinets to have the same hardware finish, light fixtures in another finish, and faucets or doorknobs in another finish). It can be intimidating, but we promise that when the final reveal comes along, it’ll feel fresh and oh-so-far away from the 90s.

RELATED: 13 Best Sherwin Williams White Paint Colors for Cabinets  

TIP #6: Keep Your Room Aesthetic Cohesive 

As a final rule, when swapping out your hardware and finishes, you want the room to remain aesthetically cohesive. The overall goal of your space design should be clear from corner to corner. If you have an ultra-modern aesthetic, avoid a more traditional-style hardware pull. Likewise, if you like things a little more classic (but still contemporary), don’t go too streamlined and modern in your fixtures. It’s all about balance and keeping things curated and collected. The ultimate intention is to make everything feel distinct, yet part of a larger whole.

Taking the Next Step: Hardware Handles, Pulls, and Knobs

While it may seem like a small detail, the right kitchen cabinet hardware can make a huge difference in creating a modern kitchen feel.

Choosing the Right Hardware for Your Kitchen

When working with a 90s home, your oak cabinets likely have dated handles or knobs that make your kitchen feel stuck in time. The good news? Replacing these is one of the easiest ways to modernize your kitchen. To achieve a fresh look, consider the following options:

• Bar Pulls: These sleek, horizontal pulls provide a minimalist, contemporary vibe. They work beautifully with white cabinets and dark cabinets alike and offer a clean look.
• Classic Round Knobs: If you prefer a traditional touch, round knobs are a versatile choice. Opt for finishes like brushed nickel, matte black, or brushed brass (aka: champagne bronze or honey bronze), for a modern twist on a classic design.
• Cup Pulls: These are a good idea if you want a farmhouse or industrial feel. They pair well with wood cabinets and wood floors, giving your kitchen a bit of vintage charm.

Selecting Finishes for a Fresh New Look

The finish of your hardware can dramatically impact your kitchen’s overall aesthetic. Here are some popular finishes to consider:

1. Matte Black: Perfect for creating contrast against white cabinets or light oak cabinets. This finish gives a clean look and works well in a modern kitchen.
2. Brushed Nickel: A timeless choice that complements nearly any paint color or wood tone. It’s a great way to add sophistication without overwhelming the space.
3. Brushed Brass: Adds warmth and a subtle touch of luxury to your kitchen cabinetry. It works particularly well with dark cabinets and can be a huge difference maker in a 90s kitchen remodel.
4. Oil-Rubbed Bronze: This finish works well if you’re maintaining elements of your 90s home but want a contemporary upgrade. It pairs nicely with wood floors and wood cabinets.

Placement Tips for Cabinet Hardware

Getting the placement right for your kitchen cabinet hardware is essential for both aesthetics and functionality. Whether you’re updating upper cabinets, drawers, or full-height cabinet doors, here are some guidelines to follow:

1. Knobs on Doors: For upper cabinets, knobs are typically placed on the lower corner of the door. On lower cabinets, they go on the upper corner. This placement maintains visual balance and keeps things ergonomic.
2. Pulls on Drawers: Horizontal bar pulls are the go-to for drawers. The length of the pull should be proportional to the width of the drawer—longer pulls for wide drawers, shorter ones for narrower drawers.
3. Consistent Placement: Ensure all your hardware is placed consistently throughout the kitchen. This attention to detail helps achieve a clean look and makes your kitchen cabinetry feel cohesive.
4. Reusing Existing Holes: A good idea to avoid extra work is to match new hardware to your existing hole spacing. This saves time and effort in drilling new holes or patching old ones.

Updating Hardware: DIY Tips for Big Impact

One of the best things about updating hardware is that it’s a project you can typically do yourself. Here’s a step-by-step guide for swapping out your old hardware:

1. Gather Tools: You’ll need a screwdriver, measuring tape, and a drill (if new holes are required). A hardware template or jig is a good idea to ensure accurate placement.
2. Remove Old Hardware: Carefully unscrew and remove the existing knobs or pulls. Keep the screws in case you need them for your new hardware.
3. Measure for New Hardware: Measure the distance between the screw holes on your old hardware to ensure your new handles or pulls will fit. For knobs, this step is simpler since they only require one screw.
4. Install New Hardware: Align the new hardware with the existing holes and screw it into place. For pulls, double-check that they are level before tightening fully.
5. Step Back and Admire: Once all the new hardware is installed, step back and take in the huge difference this simple update has made!

Inspiration for Different Kitchen Styles

Need ideas for how to pair hardware with your specific kitchen style? Here are some combinations that work well:

• Modern Kitchens: Pair white cabinets with matte black or chrome bar pulls for a minimalist aesthetic.
• Farmhouse Kitchens: Combine wood cabinets with oil-rubbed bronze cup pulls and classic knobs for a cozy, rustic feel.
• Traditional Kitchens: Stick with wood tone cabinetry and add brushed nickel hardware for a timeless, polished look.
• Contemporary Kitchens: Create a striking contrast by pairing dark cabinets with brushed brass handles and pulls.

Where to Shop Online for Quality Cabinet Hardware

When it comes to upgrading your kitchen cabinet hardware, shopping online is a great way to find a variety of styles, materials, and finishes to suit your needs. From sleek bar pulls to classic knobs, here are some reputable online stores to help you achieve a fresh new look for your kitchen, including options for oak cabinets, white cabinets, and everything in between.

1. The Home Depot

A household name, Home Depot is a great place to find a vast selection of cabinet hardware. They offer everything from modern matte black pulls to traditional brushed nickel knobs. Whether you’re refreshing upper cabinets or wood cabinets, Home Depot’s variety of finishes and styles can fit any aesthetic.

What to Expect:

• Competitive pricing
• Wide range of hardware options
• Easy-to-use online search filters
• In-store pickup or convenient delivery options

Best For: DIYers looking for affordability, availability, and trusted brands.

2. Wayfair

Wayfair is known for its extensive home décor selections, and their cabinet hardware offerings are no exception. From contemporary brushed brass pulls to farmhouse-style oil-rubbed bronze knobs, Wayfair has something for every taste.

What to Expect:

• Huge selection with frequent sales
• User reviews and detailed product descriptions
• Free shipping on many items

Best For: Those seeking variety and unique styles for a kitchen makeover.

4. Rejuvenation

If you’re looking for premium quality and timeless designs, Rejuvenation is a great place to shop for cabinet hardware. They offer handcrafted pieces with a focus on classic and contemporary styles.

What to Expect:

• High-end hardware in finishes like matte black, brushed nickel, and brass
• Detailed craftsmanship and durability
• Options for kitchen cabinetry, drawers, and upper cabinets

Best For: Those investing in long-lasting, statement-making hardware.

5. Amazon

Amazon is the go-to for quick finds and budget-friendly options.

What to Expect:

• Fast shipping options, including Prime
• Extensive customer reviews
• A mix of budget-friendly and designer options

Best For: Quick, convenient shopping and a wide selection for any kitchen remodel.

7. Lowe’s

Similar to Home Depot, Lowe’s is another reliable source for cabinet hardware. They offer a wide range of styles, from contemporary to traditional, and often have special promotions and discounts.

What to Expect:

• Quality brands and budget-friendly choices
• Easy online ordering and in-store pickup
• Hardware that complements wood floors, oak cabinets, and modern kitchens

Best For: DIY enthusiasts looking for quality at a good price.

8. Etsy

For handcrafted and custom hardware, Etsy is a fantastic option. You can find everything from vintage-style pulls to modern minimalist knobs, often made by skilled artisans.

What to Expect:

• One-of-a-kind pieces and customizable options
• Supporting small businesses and artisans
• Options for dark cabinets, white cabinets, and unique paint colors

Best For: Unique, custom-made hardware to make your kitchen stand out.

Updating your kitchen cabinet hardware is one of the easy ways and most cost-effective ways to breathe new life into a 90s kitchen. Whether you’re tackling a full kitchen remodel or just looking for a quick kitchen makeover, the right handles, pulls, and knobs can make a huge difference. It’s all about balancing personal preference with contemporary style to achieve a space that feels cohesive, updated, and uniquely yours.

Updating your kitchen cabinet hardware is one of the easy ways and most cost-effective ways to breathe new life into a 90s kitchen. Whether you’re tackling a full kitchen remodel or just looking for a quick kitchen makeover, the right handles, pulls, and knobs can make a huge difference. It’s all about balancing personal preference with contemporary style to achieve a space that feels cohesive, updated, and uniquely yours.